The Mess in New York
We make sense of the mayoral election.,
New York City released another round of results in the Democratic mayoral primary — and city officials insist that they’re accurate this time. They say they have resolved the “discrepancy” that caused them to report inaccurate results on Tuesday from their new ranked-choice voting system.
Today’s newsletter tries to sort through the mess.
Does ranked choice have to be so complicated?
In a ranked-choice system, voters don’t select only one candidate. They can rank several, in order. The goal is to let people both note their first choices and also state a preference among the others. It’s become increasingly popular in recent years.
Several cities — including Minneapolis; Portland, Maine; and Santa Fe, N.M. — manage to conduct ranked-choice voting and announce results on election night. The cities scan the ballots, and computers quickly tabulate the results, as Rob Richie, the president of FairVote, a group that advocates ranked-choice voting, told me.
Tabulating the results of a ranked-choice election is not a difficult process for modern computers.
What’s New York’s problem?
The slow and flawed counting of ballots is part of the city’s broader problems with election administration. The New York City Board of Elections has suffered from “decades of nepotism and bungling,” a Times investigation by Brian M. Rosenthal and Michael Rothfeld found last year.
As their story explained:
As the workings of American democracy have become more complex — with sophisticated technology, early voting and the threat of foreign interference — New York has clung to a century-old system of local election administration that is one of the last vestiges of pure patronage in government, a relic from the era of powerful political clubhouses and Tammany Hall. …
Some staffers read or watch Netflix at the office, the employees said. Others regularly fail to show up for work, with no fear of discipline. Several employees said some staffers punch in and then leave to go shopping or to the gym.
(Here’s a new Times story about recent chaos at the elections board.)
How is this allowed?
Part of the issue is New York State. Unlike most states, New York lets party leaders fill local election boards, rather than staffing them with nonpartisan experts.
New York State has also decided not to prioritize a quick reporting of election results. Absentee ballots can arrive up to a week after Election Day so long as they are postmarked by Election Day, and voters can later fix errors in their ballots, as Jerry Goldfeder, an elections lawyer, told my colleague Dana Rubinstein. State officials don’t start counting absentee ballots until at least a week after Election Day.
That’s why officials took weeks to release results in some congressional races last year.
The mayor’s race was another example of New York’s slowness. On primary night, the city announced only the first choices of in-person voters. A week later (this past Tuesday) came the full ranked-choice results from those voters. Not until sometime in July will the city release the absentee results.
It’s true that there are some unavoidable tensions between efficiency and voting access. But New York’s slowness also stems from a lack of competence. States with higher voter turnout report results much faster than New York does.
What about the ‘discrepancy’?
The Election Board committed a stunning error in its announcement of results on Tuesday. In its count, it included 135,000 votes that did not actually exist — made-up votes that the board had created to test its ranked-choice software. It described the mistake as a “discrepancy” in a tweet on Tuesday.
Yesterday, the board released a new count, with the made-up votes removed. But the damage to the election’s credibility is significant. “This is the most botched election results reporting by an official agency I’ve ever seen in the U.S.,” Dave Wasserman of the Cook Political Report wrote.
What are the latest results?
The new results are similar to the earlier ones, with Eric Adams having a small lead over Kathryn Garcia — of 15,000 votes, or 2.2 percentage points — in the final round. But the unreleased absentee ballots seem likely to favor Garcia, given the neighborhoods they come from, Wasserman and other election analysts noted. (It is still possible that Maya Wiley could vault over Garcia into the final two, with either Wiley or Adams then winning.)
The key reason the race has narrowed, compared with Adams’s sizable lead after the first round, is that far more of Wiley’s supporters preferred Garcia than him.
Adams ran the most conservative campaign of the three candidates and did best among working-class voters across racial groups. Wiley, the most liberal of the three, fared better among college graduates, especially those who were Black or Hispanic. Garcia was strongest among white college graduates, The Times’s Thomas Edsall noted.
I see two main takeaways: One is that working-class voters across races — even in a Democratic primary in New York City — are fairly moderate, as I described in Tuesday’s newsletter. Two is that New York suffers from some of the worst-run elections in the United States.
Democrats lost ground among Hispanic and Black voters in the 2020 national elections, a detailed polling analysis shows.
Many have tried to overhaul New York’s Board of Elections. None have succeeded.
THE LATEST NEWS
The director of the C.D.C. reiterated that vaccinated people usually did not need masks, but she said that areas with low inoculation rates might choose to enact mask mandates.
“If you are among the vaccinated, most experts say you don’t need to be fearful,” The Times’s Tara Parker-Pope writes in an explainer on the Delta variant.
Delta is fueling a rise in cases — and in countries with low vaccination rates, in deaths — around the world.
The House voted — largely along party lines — to create a special committee to investigate the Jan. 6 attack on the Capitol.
The Times’s Visual Investigations team has created a comprehensive picture of the Capitol riot.
President Biden said that he would raise the pay of federal firefighters, calling the current wage — around $13 an hour — “ridiculously low.”
Other Big Stories
Donald Rumsfeld died at 88. He served as defense secretary for two Republican presidents and was an architect of the 2003 invasion of Iraq.
A grand jury indicted the Trump Organization and Alan Weisselberg, a top executive, in a tax investigation over “fringe benefits” handed out at the company.
Commemorating 100 years of the Chinese Communist Party, Xi Jinping cast it as China’s savior and warned foreign powers not to interfere.
An international tribunal convicted two former Serbian officials of war crimes from the 1990s, closing the final case from the Balkan wars.
Those in the West who are banking on the Chinese Communist Party’s demise are mistaken, the journalist Yi-Zheng Lian argues. “The party may well outlive us all.”
On “Sway,” Kara Swisher interviews Ron Klain, the White House chief of staff.
Nickelodeon’s hitmaker: Dan Schneider once reigned over children’s TV. What happened?
An Instagram whodunit: Who is rg_bunny1?
Peek inside: Betsey Johnson’s Malibu dream house.
A Times classic: The Food desk taste-tested 10 hot dogs. Here are the best.
Lives Lived: Greg Noll, a fearless surfer known as “Da Bull,” tackled stunningly big waves in Hawaii in the 1960s. With his bodybuilder’s physique and black-and-white prison-stripe trunks he was difficult to miss in the water. Noll died at 84.
ARTS AND IDEAS
Why many tennis pros barely scrape by
In pro tennis, the biggest stars earn fortunes in prize money and endorsements. But for the rank-and-file, the sport is far less lucrative: After travel, coaching and other expenses, most players barely scrape by.
“If you are not in the top 100, you are basically not making any money,” Vasek Pospisil, a player who has been ranked as high as 25th in the world, said. Contrast that with the N.H.L., Pospisil noted, which has roughly 700 players and a guaranteed minimum salary of $700,000.
The inequality also means many players lack the resources to improve. “The players ranked 150 to 250 are on the cusp of breaking through, but they need to be able to invest in themselves,” Gaby Dabrowski, another player, said. “You need a coach to guide you, to have a vision for your tennis, to see your blind spots, and you need money for that.”
One thing that separates tennis from many other sports is that its players are not in a union. Last year, Pospisil and Novak Djokovic announced the formation of the Professional Tennis Players Association, which would negotiate on behalf of players.
The fledgling organization has yet to win the support of other top players on both the men’s and women’s sides. And it faces opposition from the game’s most powerful institutions. For more, read Michael Steinberger’s article in The Times Magazine. — Sanam Yar, a Morning writer
PLAY, WATCH, EAT
What to Cook
What to Read
Meet T.J. Newman, who wrote her debut thriller, “Falling,” while working as a flight attendant.
Mae West vamped and winked. She was also a trailblazing screenwriter in the 1930s, with an interest in lives on the margins.
The art of whistling almost died. Can a 31-year-old who has whistled in the studio for Dr. Dre keep it alive?
Now Time to Play
The pangrams from yesterday’s Spelling Bee were habitual and halibut. Here is today’s puzzle — or you can play online.
Here’s today’s Mini Crossword, and a clue: History (four letters).
If you’re in the mood to play more, find all our games here.
Thanks for spending part of your morning with The Times. See you tomorrow. — David
P.S. The word “dudealicious” appeared for the first time in The Times yesterday.
Here’s today’s print front page.